要从无向图中删除的最小标记节点，以便没有循环

给定从 1 到 N 标记的N 个节点的无向图，任务是找到应该从图中删除的最小标记节点，使得生成的图没有环。

注意：如果初始图没有环，即不需要删除节点，打印-1。

例子：

Input: N = 5, edges[][] = {{5, 1}, {5, 2}, {1, 2}, {2, 3}, {2, 4}} 
Output: 1 
Explanation: 
If node 1 is removed, the resultant graph has no cycle. Similarly, the cycle can be avoided by removing node 2 also. 
Since we have to find the minimum labelled node, the answer is 1.

Input: N = 5, edges[][] = {{4, 5}, {4, 1}, {4, 2}, {4, 3}, {5, 1}, {5, 2}} 
Output: 4  

朴素的方法：这个问题的朴素的方法是单独删除每个顶点并检查结果图是否有循环。这种方法的时间复杂度是二次的。

有效的方法：想法是在给定的图上应用深度优先搜索并观察形成的 dfs 树。

• 后边指的是不属于构建的 DFS 树的边，而是某个节点 v 和 v 的祖先之一之间的边。
• 显然，图中所有不属于 DFS 树的边都是后边。
• 如果图中没有后边，则该图没有环。因此，在这种情况下，答案将是-1 。

如果图中有后边，那么我们需要找到最小边。为了做到这一点，我们需要检查在从图中删除特定边时是否删除了循环。因此，让v成为我们当前正在检查的顶点。因此，顶点 v 必须遵循以下条件，以便在删除时不会导致循环：

• v必须位于连接图中每个后边端点的树路径上。
  证明：假设存在一些后边 xy，使得 v 不在树路径上。如果我们移除 v，我们仍然可以从 x 遍历到 y，然后通过后边返回 x，这表明循环没有被移除。
• v 的子树必须有至多一条到 v 的任何祖先的后边。
  证明：让子树 S 必须背靠边 wx 和 yz，使得 w 和 y 在 S 中，x 和 z 是 v 的祖先。如果我们删除 v，显然仍然存在由 w 到 y 之间的路径组成的循环，从 x 到 z 的路径以及两个后边缘 wx 和 yz，即循环没有被移除。

因此，这个想法是跟踪后边，以及一个节点的子树中后边数量的指示器，以指示其任何祖先。为了跟踪后边缘，我们将使用修改后的 DFS 图着色算法。
为了检查子树 v 是否有至多一个到 v 的任何祖先的后边，我们实现了 dfs，以便它返回 v 的子树中两个最高边的深度。我们维护一个数组，其中每个索引 ‘数组中的 i’ 存储节点 ‘i’ 是否满足上述条件 2。类似地，实现了两个数组，一个用于子节点，另一个用于父节点，以查看节点 v 是否位于连接端点的树路径上。

下面是上述方法的实现：

C++

// C++ implementation to find the
// minimum labelled node to be
// removed such that there is no
// cycle in the undirected graph
 
#include 
 
using namespace std;
 
const int MAX = 100005;
 
int totBackEdges;
int countAdj[MAX], small[MAX];
 
// Variables to store if a node V has
// at-most one back edge and store the
// depth of the node for the edge
int isPossible[MAX], depth[MAX];
 
vector adj[MAX];
int vis[MAX];
 
// Function to swap the pairs of the graph
void change(pair& p, int x)
{
    // If the second value is
    // greater than x
    if (p.second > x)
        p.second = x;
 
    // Put the pair in the ascending
    // order internally
    if (p.first > p.second)
        swap(p.first, p.second);
}
 
// Function to perform the DFS
pair dfs(int v, int p = -1, int de = 0)
{
    // Initialise with the large value
    pair answer(100000000, 100000000);
 
    // Storing the depth of this vertex
    depth[v] = de;
 
    // Mark the vertex as visited
    vis[v] = 1;
    isPossible[v] = 1;
 
    // Iterating through the graph
    for (int u : adj[v]) {
 
        // If the node is a child node
        if (u ^ p) {
 
            // If the child node is unvisited
            if (!vis[u]) {
 
                // Move to the child and increase
                // the depth
                auto x = dfs(u, v, de + 1);
 
                // increase according to algorithm
                small[v] += small[u];
 
                change(answer, x.second);
                change(answer, x.first);
 
                // If the node is not having
                // exactly K backedges
                if (x.second < de)
                    isPossible[v] = 0;
            }
 
            // If the child is already visited
            // and in current dfs
            // (because colour is 1)
            // then this is a back edge
            else if (vis[u] == 1) {
                totBackEdges++;
 
                // Increase the countAdj values
                countAdj[v]++;
                countAdj[u]++;
                small[p]++;
                small[u]--;
                change(answer, depth[u]);
            }
        }
    }
 
    // Colour this vertex 2 as
    // we are exiting out of
    // dfs for this node
    vis[v] = 2;
    return answer;
}
 
// Function to find the minimum labelled
// node to be removed such that
// there is no cycle in the undirected graph
int minNodetoRemove(
    int n,
    vector > edges)
{
 
    // Construct the graph
    for (int i = 0; i < edges.size(); i++) {
        adj[edges[i].first]
            .push_back(edges[i].second);
        adj[edges[i].second]
            .push_back(edges[i].first);
    }
 
    // Mark visited as false for each node
    memset(vis, 0, sizeof(vis));
 
    totBackEdges = 0;
 
    // Apply dfs on all unmarked nodes
    for (int v = 1; v <= n; v++) {
        if (!vis[v])
            dfs(v);
    }
 
    // If no backedges in the initial graph
    // this means that there is no cycle
    // So, return -1
    if (totBackEdges == 0)
        return -1;
 
    int node = -1;
 
    // Iterate through the vertices and
    // return the first node that
    // satisfies the condition
    for (int v = 1; v <= n; v++) {
 
        // Check whether the count sum of
        // small[v] and count is the same as
        // the total back edges and
        // if the vertex v can be removed
        if (countAdj[v] + small[v]
                == totBackEdges
            && isPossible[v]) {
            node = v;
        }
        if (node != -1)
            break;
    }
 
    return node;
}
 
// Driver code
int main()
{
    int N = 5;
    vector > edges;
    edges.push_back(make_pair(5, 1));
    edges.push_back(make_pair(5, 2));
    edges.push_back(make_pair(1, 2));
    edges.push_back(make_pair(2, 3));
    edges.push_back(make_pair(2, 4));
 
    cout << minNodetoRemove(N, edges);
}

Java

// Java implementation to find the
// minimum labelled node to be
// removed such that there is no
// cycle in the undirected graph
import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.Arrays;
 
class Pair
{
    int first, second;
 
    public Pair(int first, int second)
    {
        this.first = first;
        this.second = second;
    }
}
 
class GFG{
 
static final int MAX = 100005;
 
static int totBackEdges;
static int[] countAdj = new int[MAX];
static int[] small = new int[MAX];
 
// Variables to store if a node V has
// at-most one back edge and store the
// depth of the node for the edge
static int[] isPossible = new int[MAX];
static int[] depth = new int[MAX];
 
@SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
static ArrayList[] adj = new ArrayList[MAX];
 
static int[] vis = new int[MAX];
 
// Function to swap the pairs of the graph
static void change(Pair p, int x)
{
     
    // If the second value is
    // greater than x
    if (p.second > x)
        p.second = x;
 
    // Put the Pair in the ascending
    // order internally
    if (p.first > p.second)
    {
        int tmp = p.first;
        p.first = p.second;
        p.second = tmp;
    }
}
 
// Function to perform the DFS
static Pair dfs(int v, int p, int de)
{
     
    // Initialise with the large value
    Pair answer = new Pair(100000000, 100000000);
 
    // Storing the depth of this vertex
    depth[v] = de;
 
    // Mark the vertex as visited
    vis[v] = 1;
    isPossible[v] = 1;
 
    // Iterating through the graph
    for(int u : adj[v])
    {
         
        // If the node is a child node
        if ((u ^ p) != 0)
        {
             
            // If the child node is unvisited
            if (vis[u] == 0)
            {
                 
                // Move to the child and increase
                // the depth
                Pair x = dfs(u, v, de + 1);
 
                // increase according to algorithm
                small[v] += small[u];
 
                change(answer, x.second);
                change(answer, x.first);
 
                // If the node is not having
                // exactly K backedges
                if (x.second < de)
                    isPossible[v] = 0;
            }
 
            // If the child is already visited
            // and in current dfs
            // (because colour is 1)
            // then this is a back edge
            else if (vis[u] == 1)
            {
                totBackEdges++;
 
                // Increase the countAdj values
                countAdj[v]++;
                countAdj[u]++;
                small[p]++;
                small[u]--;
                change(answer, depth[u]);
            }
        }
    }
 
    // Colour this vertex 2 as
    // we are exiting out of
    // dfs for this node
    vis[v] = 2;
    return answer;
}
 
// Function to find the minimum labelled
// node to be removed such that
// there is no cycle in the undirected graph
static int minNodetoRemove(int n, ArrayList edges)
{
     
    // Construct the graph
    for(int i = 0; i < edges.size(); i++)
    {
        adj[edges.get(i).first].add(
            edges.get(i).second);
        adj[edges.get(i).second].add(
            edges.get(i).first);
    }
 
    // Mark visited as false for each node
    Arrays.fill(vis, 0);
 
    totBackEdges = 0;
 
    // Apply dfs on all unmarked nodes
    for(int v = 1; v <= n; v++)
    {
        if (vis[v] == 0)
            dfs(v, -1, 0);
    }
 
    // If no backedges in the initial graph
    // this means that there is no cycle
    // So, return -1
    if (totBackEdges == 0)
        return -1;
 
    int node = -1;
 
    // Iterate through the vertices and
    // return the first node that
    // satisfies the condition
    for(int v = 1; v <= n; v++)
    {
         
        // Check whether the count sum of
        // small[v] and count is the same as
        // the total back edges and
        // if the vertex v can be removed
        if ((countAdj[v] + small[v] == totBackEdges) &&
           isPossible[v] != 0)
        {
            node = v;
        }
         
        if (node != -1)
            break;
    }
    return node;
}
 
// Driver code
public static void main(String[] args)
{
    int N = 5;
     
    ArrayList edges = new ArrayList<>();
    for(int i = 0; i < MAX; i++)
    {
        adj[i] = new ArrayList<>();
    }
     
    edges.add(new Pair(5, 1));
    edges.add(new Pair(5, 2));
    edges.add(new Pair(1, 2));
    edges.add(new Pair(2, 3));
    edges.add(new Pair(2, 4));
 
    System.out.println(minNodetoRemove(N, edges));
}
}
 
// This code is contributed by sanjeev2552

Python3

# Python3 implementation to find the
# minimum labelled node to be
# removed such that there is no
# cycle in the undirected graph 
MAX = 100005; 
totBackEdges = 0
countAdj = [0 for i in range(MAX)]
small = [0 for i in range(MAX)]
   
# Variables to store if a node V has
# at-most one back edge and store the
# depth of the node for the edge
isPossible = [0 for i in range(MAX)]
depth = [0 for i in range(MAX)]
adj = [[] for i in range(MAX)]
vis = [0 for i in range(MAX)]
 
# Function to swap the pairs of the graph
def change(p, x):
 
    # If the second value is
    # greater than x
    if (p[1] > x):
        p[1] = x;
   
    # Put the pair in the ascending
    # order internally
    if (p[0] > p[1]):
     
       tmp = p[0];
       p[0] = p[1];
       p[1] = tmp;
      
# Function to perform the DFS
def dfs(v, p = -1, de = 0):
    global vis, totBackEdges
     
    # Initialise with the large value
    answer = [100000000, 100000000]
   
    # Storing the depth of this vertex
    depth[v] = de;
   
    # Mark the vertex as visited
    vis[v] = 1;
    isPossible[v] = 1;
   
    # Iterating through the graph
    for u in adj[v]:
   
        # If the node is a child node
        if ((u ^ p) != 0):
   
            # If the child node is unvisited
            if (vis[u] == 0):
   
                # Move to the child and increase
                # the depth
                x = dfs(u, v, de + 1);
   
                # increase according to algorithm
                small[v] += small[u];
   
                change(answer, x[1]);
                change(answer, x[0]);
   
                # If the node is not having
                # exactly K backedges
                if (x[1] < de):
                    isPossible[v] = 0;
   
            # If the child is already visited
            # and in current dfs
            # (because colour is 1)
            # then this is a back edge
            elif (vis[u] == 1):
                totBackEdges += 1
   
                # Increase the countAdj values
                countAdj[v] += 1
                countAdj[u] += 1
                small[p] += 1
                small[u] -= 1
                change(answer, depth[u]);
               
    # Colour this vertex 2 as
    # we are exiting out of
    # dfs for this node
    vis[v] = 2;
    return answer;
   
# Function to find the minimum labelled
# node to be removed such that
# there is no cycle in the undirected graph
def minNodetoRemove( n, edges):
   
    # Construct the graph
    for i in range(len(edges)):
     
        adj[edges[i][0]].append(edges[i][1]);
        adj[edges[i][1]].append(edges[i][0]);
         
    global vis, totBackEdges
     
    # Mark visited as false for each node
    vis = [0 for i in range(len(vis))] 
    totBackEdges = 0;
   
    # Apply dfs on all unmarked nodes
    for v in range(1, n + 1):  
        if (vis[v] == 0):
            dfs(v);
      
    # If no backedges in the initial graph
    # this means that there is no cycle
    # So, return -1
    if (totBackEdges == 0):
        return -1; 
    node = -1;
   
    # Iterate through the vertices and
    # return the first node that
    # satisfies the condition
    for v in range(1, n + 1):
   
        # Check whether the count sum of
        # small[v] and count is the same as
        # the total back edges and
        # if the vertex v can be removed
        if ((countAdj[v] + small[v] == totBackEdges) and isPossible[v] != 0):
            node = v;      
        if (node != -1):
            break; 
    return node;
   
# Driver code
if __name__=='__main__':   
    N = 5;
    edges = []
    edges.append([5, 1]);
    edges.append([5, 2]);
    edges.append([1, 2]);
    edges.append([2, 3]);
    edges.append([2, 4]); 
    print(minNodetoRemove(N, edges));
 
    # This code is contributed by Pratham76

C#

// C# implementation to find the
// minimum labelled node to be
// removed such that there is no
// cycle in the undirected graph
  
using System;
using System.Collections;
using System.Collections.Generic;
 
class GFG
{
  
static int MAX = 100005;
  
static int totBackEdges;
static int []countAdj = new int[MAX];
static int []small = new int[MAX];
  
// Variables to store if a node V has
// at-most one back edge and store the
// depth of the node for the edge
static int []isPossible = new int[MAX];
static int []depth = new int[MAX];
 
static ArrayList adj = new ArrayList();
 
static int []vis = new int[MAX];
 
class pair
{
    public int first, second;
    public pair(int first, int second)
    {
        this.first = first;
        this.second = second;
    }
}
  
// Function to swap the pairs of the graph
static void change(ref pair p, int x)
{
    // If the second value is
    // greater than x
    if (p.second > x)
        p.second = x;
  
    // Put the pair in the ascending
    // order internally
    if (p.first > p.second)
    { 
       int tmp = p.first;
       p.first = p.second;
       p.second = tmp;
    }
}
  
// Function to perform the DFS
static pair dfs(int v, int p = -1, int de = 0)
{
    // Initialise with the large value
    pair answer = new pair(100000000, 100000000);
  
    // Storing the depth of this vertex
    depth[v] = de;
  
    // Mark the vertex as visited
    vis[v] = 1;
    isPossible[v] = 1;
  
    // Iterating through the graph
    foreach (int u in (ArrayList)adj[v]) {
  
        // If the node is a child node
        if ((u ^ p) != 0) {
  
            // If the child node is unvisited
            if (vis[u] == 0) {
  
                // Move to the child and increase
                // the depth
                pair x = dfs(u, v, de + 1);
  
                // increase according to algorithm
                small[v] += small[u];
  
                change(ref answer, x.second);
                change(ref answer, x.first);
  
                // If the node is not having
                // exactly K backedges
                if (x.second < de)
                    isPossible[v] = 0;
            }
  
            // If the child is already visited
            // and in current dfs
            // (because colour is 1)
            // then this is a back edge
            else if (vis[u] == 1) {
                totBackEdges++;
  
                // Increase the countAdj values
                countAdj[v]++;
                countAdj[u]++;
                small[p]++;
                small[u]--;
                change(ref answer, depth[u]);
            }
        }
    }
  
    // Colour this vertex 2 as
    // we are exiting out of
    // dfs for this node
    vis[v] = 2;
    return answer;
}
  
// Function to find the minimum labelled
// node to be removed such that
// there is no cycle in the undirected graph
static int minNodetoRemove(
    int n,
    ArrayList edges)
{
  
    // Construct the graph
    for (int i = 0; i < edges.Count; i++) {
        ((ArrayList)adj[((pair)edges[i]).first])
            .Add(((pair)edges[i]).second);
        ((ArrayList)adj[((pair)edges[i]).second])
            .Add(((pair)edges[i]).first);
    }
  
    // Mark visited as false for each node
    Array.Fill(vis, 0);
  
    totBackEdges = 0;
  
    // Apply dfs on all unmarked nodes
    for (int v = 1; v <= n; v++) {
        if (vis[v] == 0)
            dfs(v);
    }
  
    // If no backedges in the initial graph
    // this means that there is no cycle
    // So, return -1
    if (totBackEdges == 0)
        return -1;
  
    int node = -1;
  
    // Iterate through the vertices and
    // return the first node that
    // satisfies the condition
    for (int v = 1; v <= n; v++) {
  
        // Check whether the count sum of
        // small[v] and count is the same as
        // the total back edges and
        // if the vertex v can be removed
        if ((countAdj[v] + small[v] == totBackEdges) && isPossible[v] != 0) {
            node = v;
        }
        if (node != -1)
            break;
    }
  
    return node;
}
  
// Driver code
static void Main()
{
    int N = 5;
    ArrayList edges = new ArrayList();
    for(int i = 0; i < MAX; i++)
    {
        adj.Add(new ArrayList());
    }
    edges.Add(new pair(5, 1));
    edges.Add(new pair(5, 2));
    edges.Add(new pair(1, 2));
    edges.Add(new pair(2, 3));
    edges.Add(new pair(2, 4));
  
    Console.Write(minNodetoRemove(N, edges));
  }
}
 
// This code is contributed by rutvik_56

Javascript

 
// Javascript implementation to find the
// minimum labelled node to be
// removed such that there is no
// cycle in the undirected graph
var MAX = 100005;
var totBackEdges;
var countAdj = Array(MAX).fill(0);
var small = Array(MAX).fill(0);
 
// Variables to store if a node V has
// at-most one back edge and store the
// depth of the node for the edge
var isPossible = Array(MAX).fill(0);
var depth = Array(MAX).fill(0);
 
var adj = [];
var vis = Array(MAX).fill(0);
 
class pair
{
    constructor(first, second)
    {
        this.first = first;
        this.second = second;
    }
}
  
// Function to swap the pairs of the graph
function change(p, x)
{
     
    // If the second value is
    // greater than x
    if (p.second > x)
        p.second = x;
  
    // Put the pair in the ascending
    // order internally
    if (p.first > p.second)
    {
        var tmp = p.first;
        p.first = p.second;
        p.second = tmp;
    }
}
  
// Function to perform the DFS
function dfs(v, p = -1, de = 0)
{
     
    // Initialise with the large value
    var answer = new pair(100000000, 100000000);
  
    // Storing the depth of this vertex
    depth[v] = de;
  
    // Mark the vertex as visited
    vis[v] = 1;
    isPossible[v] = 1;
  
    // Iterating through the graph
    for(var u of adj[v])
    {
         
        // If the node is a child node
        if ((u ^ p) != 0)
        {
             
            // If the child node is unvisited
            if (vis[u] == 0)
            {
                 
                // Move to the child and increase
                // the depth
                var x = dfs(u, v, de + 1);
  
                // Increase according to algorithm
                small[v] += small[u];
  
                change(answer, x.second);
                change(answer, x.first);
  
                // If the node is not having
                // exactly K backedges
                if (x.second < de)
                    isPossible[v] = 0;
            }
  
            // If the child is already visited
            // and in current dfs
            // (because colour is 1)
            // then this is a back edge
            else if (vis[u] == 1)
            {
                totBackEdges++;
  
                // Increase the countAdj values
                countAdj[v]++;
                countAdj[u]++;
                small[p]++;
                small[u]--;
                change(answer, depth[u]);
            }
        }
    }
  
    // Colour this vertex 2 as
    // we are exiting out of
    // dfs for this node
    vis[v] = 2;
    return answer;
}
  
// Function to find the minimum labelled
// node to be removed such that
// there is no cycle in the undirected graph
function minNodetoRemove(n, edges)
{
     
    // Construct the graph
    for(var i = 0; i < edges.length; i++)
    {
        (adj[(edges[i]).first]).push(
            (edges[i]).second);
        (adj[(edges[i]).second]).push(
            (edges[i]).first);
    }
  
    // Mark visited as false for each node
    vis = Array(MAX).fill(0);
  
    totBackEdges = 0;
  
    // Apply dfs on all unmarked nodes
    for(var v = 1; v <= n; v++)
    {
        if (vis[v] == 0)
            dfs(v);
    }
  
    // If no backedges in the initial graph
    // this means that there is no cycle
    // So, return -1
    if (totBackEdges == 0)
        return -1;
  
    var node = -1;
  
    // Iterate through the vertices and
    // return the first node that
    // satisfies the condition
    for(var v = 1; v <= n; v++)
    {
         
        // Check whether the count sum of
        // small[v] and count is the same as
        // the total back edges and
        // if the vertex v can be removed
        if ((countAdj[v] + small[v] == totBackEdges) &&
            isPossible[v] != 0)
        {
            node = v;
        }
        if (node != -1)
            break;
    }
    return node;
}
  
// Driver code
var N = 5;
var edges = [];
for(var i = 0; i < MAX; i++)
{
    adj.push(new Array());
}
 
edges.push(new pair(5, 1));
edges.push(new pair(5, 2));
edges.push(new pair(1, 2));
edges.push(new pair(2, 3));
edges.push(new pair(2, 4));
 
document.write(minNodetoRemove(N, edges));
 
// This code is contributed by rrrtnx
 

输出：

1

时间复杂度： O(N + M) ，其中 N 是节点数，M 是边数。